Lannan Seminar

Lannan Seminar
notebooks

Tuesday, February 17, 2015

Amaranth

Amaranth

This is not water. This is ice.
This is not sound. This is music.

During distillation we lose the molecules
of our origins. Light
seeps into the coffin.
Atoms form covalent bonds.

Borders of being are more fluid
than the blossoming orchid
or the breaking vase.
Lungs wreathed in smoke breathe still.

This is not salt. This is ocean.
This is not soil. This is earth.

Choose now whether to begin again
or sleep. But do not be fooled.

Darkness does not bring rest.

~Adri Smith

12 comments:

  1. Your anaphora was very effective in creating intrigue and adding emphasis to the point you were making in your work.

    ReplyDelete
  2. As Taylor noted, I think the anaphora here is one of the poem's strongest features. It's also almost didactic, with it's instruction: this is not... this is, so I'm intrigued to know who the speaker is here.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with Taylor and Kayla that the anaphora in this piece is quite powerful. I would be interested to see the subjects of your "this is not... this is..." lines explored in more detail in the body of the poem, although perhaps that is not what you had in mind when you were writing. Additionally, I thought the line breaks in this piece were very intriguing. For example, in the second stanza you end the second line with "Light," beginning a new sentence but continuing it on the next line. I'd be interested to know if there was any specific stylistic plan behind this choice, or if you just liked the flow more this way.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The structure of this poem reminds me of James Fenton’s poem, “Requiem,” (It isn’t the houses. It is the space between the houses., etc.). A very powerful way of proceeding—to write about what things are in terms of what they are not. and of course, with “coffin” and “lungs wreathed in smoke” we know that a death has occurred, or else we are meditating on death itself, and what happens when matter (the human body, for example) dissolves into the cosmos. The poem concerns the idea that the human has a choice about whether to “sleep” or to live again, but insists that the end is not the end. Very powerful.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This reminds me of the poetry of Jo Shapcott - particularly her interest in and incorporation of biological or molecular concepts. I also get the sense of "found text" in the first statement of the second stanza and the final line, as they present themselves as complete but disjointed thoughts without the need for elaboration. All together, the poem felt nicely concise and polished.

    ReplyDelete
  6. As Professor Forche says above, the structure of this poem is actually one of its more striking features. I really like how unified this piece, particularly given the constraints of the assignment. My only suggestion would be to clean up wording in some places, but that seems to be touched on already by others.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Adri, I admire your diction and lineation in this piece. You use scientific terminology to meditate on death, and yet for me this poem seemed to almost take on an almost metaphysical feeling toward the end. I also admire your command of enjambment and end stopping throughout.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I have to agree with the other respondents that the lineation contributes to the power of this poem. There is a kinetic feel that propels the poem and the images. I am impressed that you were able to use three of the alliterative words from the list. I'll be interested to read/hear it once you've made the diction substitutions.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I have to agree with the other respondents that the lineation contributes to the power of this poem. There is a kinetic feel that propels the poem and the images. I am impressed that you were able to use three of the alliterative words from the list. I'll be interested to read/hear it once you've made the diction substitutions.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Really great! I agree with Samantha and Dimitra's comments about the molecular concepts and scientific terminology in the poem. That language is a great addition to the assignment and shapes your piece. The two verse paragraphs are enveloped between the declarative sentences "This is not x. This is y."

    ReplyDelete
  11. This poem communicates an almost metaphysical argument about transformation—its incompleteness, what’s lost in translation, etc.—through concrete details and interesting turns of phrase that keep the reader’s attention. Maybe I’m misreading this, but I particularly appreciate the contrast between materials (“salt,” not “ocean”) and between types of lines, so to speak: the ‘thesis’ (“During distillation / we lose the molecules / of our origins”) and the ‘examples’ (“Light / seeps into the coffin. / Atoms form covalent bonds”) that are well set out and that culminate in what feels like a present moment that gives us the ‘problem’ — that “Darkness does not bring rest.”

    ReplyDelete
  12. This is really a great poem, and I think it's power was enhanced when you read it aloud in class (you have a great reading voice). Coming at this poem a week later, I have to admit that some of the changes you were forced to make with the second week's poem surprised me in positive ways. I'd like to see you keep some aspects of the original--like the lineation, of course--but surprise us further with some of those shocking changes from the revised poem! Great work!

    ReplyDelete