Accidents Happened.
Memory;
doors shut and open again. My mind whirs like the wheels of that blue Civic.
Music hums in the background. But the melody was off. Nathan’s older brother
Christian was a musician. He was always on time. Everything still, but the
speedometer read something like sixty five as Christian’s Blue Civic was
drifting down Highway Seventy.
Light flashed, but
no photograph could hold the moment together. Limbs fractured and split like
the charred ashen bits of that Blue Civic. It took city officials hours to
scavenge through the scene. Paramedics on site would describe his death as
“likely painless.”
It’s funny how
quickly we try to open people up to comfort.
Twelve years old, staring at the smoke seething from the scene, nothing
seems more agonizing. I can still hear Nathan echo again and again, “At least
he wasn’t in pain. At least he wasn’t in pain.”
"photograph could hold the moment together"...amazing.
ReplyDeleteGreat how you follow up the "likely painless" with an observation that opens the piece to bigger themes and questions.
This is a prose poem that is broken into three paragraphs/stanzas. The scene depicted is that of a (deadly?) car crash. There are three characters--Nathan, the speaker, and the person that was in the fateful car. This occurred when the speaker was 12, and the speaker is obviously still effected by the terrible memory but, as the last paragraph tells us, is ultimately growing from the scene.
ReplyDeleteIf you're open for comments, I'd say the second and third paragraphs are solid! The first was a bit confusing for me as the speaker transitions between metaphorical language and the challenge of telling us this story. It wasn't until the last part of the poem that I realized what was truly happening. So, I think you should work at making the first bit a little clearer. Do you need to tell us, "Nathan's older brother Christian was a musician. He was always on time." ...? And if you're not willing to cut this part, then try to incorporate something later on that makes these little facts relevant to the poem as a whole.
The short, choppy sentences here are incredibly effective - they really mirror how memory works - flashes here and there, short bits pieced together into some coherent story. I like that. It feels genuine. As Michael mentioned, the line "light flashed, but no photograph could hold the moment together" is truly striking.
ReplyDeleteThis is a poignant poem about an accident that resulted in the death of someone known to the speaker of the poem, and identified as the brother of a friend. I’m not sure that the title is quite right yet, perhaps something more closely related to this particular event or the remembering of it? The way you work with the music here is interesting, and also the inadequacy of the photograph. With a few precise details, you evoke the scene of the accident very well. And then you shift to remembering something the figure Nathan kept repeating. That reaction (repetition is, of course, common during episodes of shock). I think you might consider what the smoke was actually seething from—it wasn’t from “the scene” but rather perhaps from the wreckage? The “scene” is a term used by police and first-responders to cordon off an area to be examined. The young observer, however, would see the actual debris or wreckage, and might even try to decipher what it was.
ReplyDeleteI found this poem's narrative to be very compelling and, given the difficulties in making a coherent narrative within the constraints of this assignment, really respected your work. I think some of the wording could be tightened, but generally this was a lovely piece.
ReplyDeleteThis piece is a prose poem or a very short work of flash fiction. The writer seems to be remembering the death of a friend in a car accident many years ago. What I thought was very strong about this piece was the use of short, almost fractured sentences in the first two paragraphs. The disconnected images and almost dissociative tone both speak to profound shock, incomprehension of the situation, and sorrow that I feel are very true to life.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, some of the phrasing in the third paragraph could be changed. I stumbled over "seething" as a description for smoke, and the tone of "It's funny how quickly we try to open people up to comfort" didn't really fit with the rest of the piece.
It's remarkable how evocative this is with only 150 words. The contrast between the 12-year-old's view of the "agonizing" scene and "At least he wasn't in pain" is jarring, thought provoking.
ReplyDeleteI like the use of contrast in this synthesis of poetry and prose: door (of memory) shutting and opening, melody versus rhythm, on and off, 65 mph down Highway 70. Given the strength of the language throughout the poem, the ambiguity of the expression "It's funny how..." doesn't resonate with me as much, although I like the tonal shift that it creates.
ReplyDeleteOverall, a it's a powerful, grim piece. I can feel the loss in it.
The speaker tells a story excellently and fully with a very short word count, which I found amazing. The imagery is strong and shows but does not tell, and the characters, even though they are only mentioned quickly, are full and bring the very tragic story to life.
ReplyDelete