Blackness Visible
Claudia Rankine’s poems explore how to write about
yourself when your language pretends you don’t exist.
The
poem that started it all, Hoagland’s “The Change,” isn’t
actually all that interesting—at least not to me. But it fails, in my opinion,
not because it’s racist but, in a sense, because it’s not. Hoagland works so
hard to make the speaker’s racism cartoonishly unreal, to avoid the risk of
inhabiting any racism that might come to life on the page, in his voice, that
the poem’s final reckoning with racism can be as small and soft as “it was past
us / and we were changed.”
According
to Rankine, when she went to talk to Hoagland about the poem, he brushed her
off by saying “this poem is for white people.” In his written
response (which is occasionally interesting, persistently
condescending, and occasionally absurd: Who thinks “the topic of race belongs
only to brown-skinned Americans”?), Hoagland declined to respond to that
accusation.
But
assuming that he did say it, beyond all that’s awful in the phrase “for white
people,” there’s something worth discussing there, too, and it shows up in the
fact that the same poem that seems to me, a white reader, to hold racism at too
great a distance strikes plenty of black readers as glaringly racist.
Ironically, Rankine’s new book, Citizen: An
American Lyric, invokes that difference far more
interestingly than “The Change.”
Citizen gets at that basic disparity through a deceptively
simple trick: For much of the book, Rankine describes her encounters with
perceived racism in short prose narratives in which she refers to herself as
“you,” insisting that each reader stand in her place—which we necessarily
arrive at from very different angles.
One of
the earlier sections opens:
You are in the dark, in the car, watching the black-tarred street being
swallowed by speed; he tells you his dean is making him hire a person of color
when there are so many great writers out there.
The
descriptions are willfully plain, brief and numerous, and the efficiency of
Rankine’s prose lets them build up with the force of fact. They are, of course,
not as objective as they feel, but that’s part of the point. When I—someone
more likely to stand in the place of an offending friend or colleague than that
of Rankine—pull away from the “you” in one story, I’m forced to register my
choice to stand apart and its refusal of Rankine’s experience. Reading about a
friend who failed to speak up for her in a supermarket, I say, “But maybe
that’s not what it meant.” And when I do, I’m forced to actually feel, in
that moment of saying that I am not “you,” just how much I enter
our shared language through a set of experiences that are in no way universal.
Citizen is
one of the best books I’ve ever wanted not to read.
Rankine
doesn’t claim that her encounters with race and language are universal, either.
Instead, she’s interested in the depth of our subjectivity, which extends
beyond our varied perspectives to the ways in which we are subject to each
other. As in the AWP lecture (most of that lecture reappears, in different
forms, in Citizen—though the discussion of “The Change” is replaced
by a remarkably nuanced story of watching Serena Williams, the tennis player
that poem described), she refers to a lecture by the philosopher Judith Butler:
Not long ago you are in a room where someone asks the philosopher Judith
Butler what makes language hurtful. You can feel everyone lean in. Our very
being exposes us to the address of another, she answers. We suffer from the
condition of being addressable.
Addressability is at the heart of Citizen, the reason that
her “you” marshals such immediate force and leaves behind such intimate unease.
It’s the reason that “for white people” is so problematic, even outside its
historical echoes. In saying, even implicitly, who we’re speaking to, we say
who we’re willing to exclude. Such talk imagines a culture based on the absence
of some people, and in doing so, it addresses those people, too. Before
recounting the Judith Butler lecture, Rankine writes about an author who says
“context” is what makes things funny. At first, the “you” here is that other
author’s audience—or, more accurately, the part of that audience he perceives:
After a pause he adds that if someone said
something, like about someone, and you were with your friends you would
probably laugh, but if they said it out in public where black people could hear
what was said, you might not, probably would not. Only then do you realize you
are among "the others out in public" and not among
"friends."
More
than 40 pages in, for just that one sentence, “you” means someone else. It
imagines—assumes—an all-white audience and, in the process, erases Rankine, who
will resume the role or “you” one sentence later. That small, momentary shift
makes the stakes of her approach unmistakable. To be black, Citizen insists,
is to be audibly, palpably, invisible, and the book is in large part a struggle
to make that feeling tangible. As she notes, “a friend once told you there
exists the medical term—John Henryism—for people exposed to stresses stemming
from racism. They achieve themselves to death trying to dodge the buildup of
erasure.”
Citizen does much of its work in the body of the readers
who stand in for her. One of the marvels of Rankine’s writing is that it so
consistently embodies the ways in which the harm done by language turns to
flesh, enduring at an almost cellular level, even while she forgoes the sonic
fretwork that typically makes poetic language real. Her strict control
registers the strain of writing only in ways that will protect her from racist
judgments, of her constant awareness that “witnessing the expression of this
more ordinary and daily anger might make the witness believe that a person is
‘insane.’ ”
About a third of the way into the book, Citizen loosens
its grip somewhat, taking on more public—and more disastrously physical—events.
In a series of “Scripts for Situation Videos” that Rankine created with her
husband, John Lucas, she addresses Katrina, the murders of Trayvon Martin and
James Craig Anderson, and the prosecution of the Jena Six, among others.
Paradoxically, these scripts lack some of the
physical immediacy of her more personal narratives; there’s something missing,
something slightly more familiar, in their records of the way the supposedly
sane language of mass media removes each new outrage’s significance. That’s not
to say that they aren’t fundamental to the book. The depth to which actual
violence roots in the blindness of our speaking is essential to Rankine’s
argument—that in persistently erasing the reality of being black, we’re
damaging the very same, very human bodies we fail to recognize. The book would
have felt imbalanced without them. But it’s on the other side of these that Citizenonce
again shows the incredible ways in which Rankine makes range out of
restriction.
Trying to pull free of the second person, as if
doing so might be the first step away from illness, too (“The start of you,
each day, / a presence already— // Hey you—”), Rankine allows herself to move
into verse, though only for a few pages. The healing that these final passages
hope for is not altogether a hopeful one. (It’s surely no accident that the
book concludes with one of the almost 20 images she includes, rather than
words.) But it does, as Rankine begins referring to herself, occasionally, as
“I,” make room for the intimacy of some other “you,” someone with whom she can
share a language that embodies the persistent, heavy burden of being so
prominently erased.
There’s one last scene with a friend near the end,
and it’s the first time she and another person manage to share an awareness of
the situation they inhabit in very different ways. For the first time, the
“you” expands into a second-person plural:
When the waitress hands your friend the card she
took from you, you laugh and ask what else her privilege gets her? Oh, my
perfect life, she answers. Then you both are laughing so hard, everyone in the
restaurant smiles.
As I was reading Citizen one more
time to make some final notes, a police officer in Ferguson, Missouri, shot and
killed Michael Brown, an unarmed black 18-year-old. For almost a week, the
officer remained nameless, and his invisibility—so different from the
invisibility Rankine writes about, from Brown’s invisibility at the other end
of the officer’s gun—kept pulling my thoughts back to Citizen, a
book that, after multiple readings, I would still notice myself circling,
literally, pushing myself to pick it up.
It is one of the best books I’ve ever
wanted not to read. Citizen would inevitably be a
different book for someone who had experienced race in different ways than I
have, and yet it would, I imagine, be every bit as important. Its genius—and after
having spent so much time, some of it reluctant, with this book, I do think
that word is appropriate—resides in that capacity to make so many different
versions of American life proper to itself, to instruct us in the depth and
variety of our participation in a narrative of race that we recount and
reinstate, even when we speak as though it weren’t there.
---
Citizen: An
American Lyric by Claudia Rankine. Graywolf Press.
No comments:
Post a Comment