Lannan Seminar

Lannan Seminar
notebooks

Tuesday, February 17, 2015

The Archaeology of Hope

Steven Minas
Georgetown University

The Archaeology of Hope


We stood near the ice, peering across the covered passage as the objects were removed: a small golden coffin with turquoise flecks on its base was raised first, then a scroll, with half-torn leaves, exposing a list of names (Anastasia, Chloe, Dima), came second. The hands of the workers carefully separated the objects, lifting a third, unrecognizable, indecipherable, though radiant object, and placing it next to the others. As day-light began to diminish, so did the onlookers. Some carried away a new sense of wonder, others, an inveterate belief in the insufficiency of the pagan mysteries to provide grace. But the remaining few knew the origin of the golden pithos (a mistranslation by Erasmus), or pyxis, and Anesidora’s tale, a tale once fabled, but now confirmed by this discovery in the shale of the field. As it is told, he could not forgive the Titan’s transgression, so he asked the smith to shape her out of water and earth. Once formed, with additional gifts from the Gods, they provided her with a golden coffin and instructions not to open it. Whether it was curiosity or just poor communication, all that remains of the box, which lies empty on the table, is a single word: Elpis.

11 comments:

  1. Your fusion of history in your work creates a heightened meaning to your work, giving words and connotations a purpose in your pieces. Well done!

    ReplyDelete
  2. The speaker here feels removed in a way that seems consistent with epic poetry (though it's been a while since I've read any...). Still, I wonder about the speaker (this is more a question of curiosity rather than a editing suggestion): what kind of relationship does the speaker have to this discovery (especially since the poem originally gestures towards a "we")?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Steven, I think this is the first time I've seen you write a prose poem (with the exception of the footnotes that you included in your poetry last semester), and I love it!!!

    The poem depicts of a scene with a "we" voice. They are excavating and find an object that is mysterious to readers. All we are given is the fact that is "radiant" and "indecipherable." I loved the mystery of it--I was dying to know what it was they found!

    The poem then continues to tell of how a community/crowd saw this object and left, some with wonder, and others knew of some sort of origin that is later told to us.

    The poem ends powerfully and I think the ending is the best part. I had to google the word "Elpis" which made the image of the empty box, laying on the table, all the more powerful. It also made the title that much more compelling. I also like that the reader had to excavate, a lot like the characters within the poem, to find the meaning of the poem.

    If you're open for comments, I would like to see you expand this sentence: "As it is told, he could not forgive the Titan's transgression..." I have no background in this, and I'm sure most readers here wouldn't understand what's going on. I'd like a little more background about being shaped into water and earth.

    Of course, if you'd like the reader to work like an archeologist in understanding the background of the fable, then leave as is!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I really enjoyed this piece - the references you make to myth, while containing enough information for someone who is not necessarily well-versed in the subject to pick up on what you're referring to, are unclear enough to prompt further investigation. This seems to be by design, and I don't think it is something you should change. The ending is an excellent example of this, completing the tale of Pandora's box without referencing the conventional, well-known names central to the story.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This is a wonderful anecdote, or scholarly note, but to be a more, it might require further compression and a less explanatory tone. You might consider some revisions (suggested in the edited version I have proposed to you here):
    We stood near the ice, peering across the covered passage: a small golden coffin with turquoise flecks on its base was raised first, then a scroll with half-torn leaves, exposing a list of names (Anastasia, Chloe, Dima). The hands of the workers lifted a third, indecipherable, though radiant thing, and placing it beside the others. As daylight diminished the onlookers carried a sense of wonder. The remaining few knew the origin of the golden pithos, or pyxis, and Anesidora’s tale, once fabled, now confirmed through this discovery in the shale of the field. As it is told, he could not forgive the Titan, so he asked the smith to shape her (?) out of water and earth. Once formed, with additional gifts from the Gods, they provided her a golden coffin with instructions not to open it. All that remains of the box, empty on the table, is a single word: Elpis.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Your command of mythology is phenomenal. I would like to reiterate what Kayla has said, though: I am curious about the speaker's connection to the events taking place before him/her. An interesting avenue to pursue with this may be stringing that "we" back through the anecdote.

    ReplyDelete
  7. You really did an excellent job using classical figures in this work. I appreciated what you did to personify these distant and at times austere figures. I generally concur with much of what is said in the above comments in terms of word edits.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Kudos for fitting your classical theme into this poetry exercise. More than just the references, I enjoyed that the poem itself was its own myth in its retelling - "We stood near the ice" places the reader inside the narrative. I agree with Professor Forche that you might want to make the poem sound slightly less didactic, though I appreciated some of the explanations since I'm not too well-versed in these allusions

    ReplyDelete
  9. The piece is interesting, particularly in the way in which it is so completely different from all the other pieces--it is academic, scholarly, and dense (almost an essay). It certainly sounds didactic, but that does not bother me that much because of its style. The real question I had as I read is: who are you writing to? This piece (as some of your past pieces) is clearly to be appreciated by a very specific audience and excludes most everyone else. Which is totally fine with me, but perhaps worth considering: do you want others to be able to access your writing?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Your writing always leaves me wishing I knew more about ancient mythology! There is such an inherent mystery and romance and even foreboding to this subject matter - and your treatment of it preserves that sense. The increasing ambiguity of the speaker throughout this short piece lent the impression of an opening into - or introduction of - a longer narrative to follow.

    ReplyDelete