I often reject my progression by closing my eyes,
When I lift my lids again, I have returned to a world, now dead.
My youth is a city of cinder.
I shelter my face with wrinkling hands as wind shrines me in coppery dust
And there is my rusty piano—
The one I sweated over for hours (The one, I was sure, would make me famous),
The keys have prickled off, the wood is now wilted,
my refuge: a trophy of broken ambition.
Coughing beneath my childhood treasure I hear my own laughing voice through the dust.
I open my mouth, but her voice has trailed off, lifted away with girlhood sincerity.
A photograph then drops from the broken keys to my hands,
I wipe away the grime, find myself with a toy gun in hand.
I was the cowgirl I truly believed I was.
But the picture slips through my fingers and sways through the rubble,
ash swoops across, takes her further, further away.
This piece possesses a rare poignancy, and is very effective in conveying emotion and a sense of nostalgia.
ReplyDeleteThe voice here is genuine and honest (especially the line in the parenthesis, since it gives the piece an almost confessional feel). The third stanza really emphasizes the separation between girlhood and adulthood for the speaker since the third person creates a different referent. I wonder how this would work as a list poem, experiencing the speaker looking for her girlhood in a series of objects (which the poem already mentions)?
ReplyDeleteThis piece takes an interesting approach to discussing the inevitability of the passage of time. What could be taken as a vision of the future or an observation of the present in the rusty piano is followed by a picture of the past, which is then lost, moving further and further away. I thought this ending was particularly effective at communicating a forlorn tone regarding something that cannot be changed.
ReplyDeleteThis piece seems to ponder about a sense of lost youth; lots of "I" and "me" and the use of a pronoun "her" which I suppose is in reference to the speaker's self. I like the literal interaction between the present and the past in those lines, especially your last stanza's opening line.
ReplyDeleteThis definitely worked to challenge conceptions of the self and of age. I liked the way you played with the ages, and language characterizing age, between the characters. This definitely was a cerebral poem and I'm not sure what to make of all of it at this point. This may be a good thing, but it may mean that some of the language could be demystified and tightened.
ReplyDeleteThis is a poignant poem about loss (loss of childhood, of various hopes. Three stanzas. Here are my thoughts: I’m not sure what you mean by “progression” in the first line. Do you mean “life”? This throws me a little. Do you mean that you wish to say you reject is around you? I think a bit more clarity, right at the beginning would help here. I think “shelter” is an interesting word, but really I think you mean something much more direct: “cover.” Because you have so much else going on in the rest of that line (shrine, coppery dust). I like the move toward the piano and all that the speaker has to say about it. I don’t know about the word “prickled.” What do you mean by this? I think you might begin the third stanza with its second line. Perhaps “I am the cowgirl I truly believed I was.” And I would like this as the last line!
ReplyDeleteOne thing that I am still hung up on in your poem (in a good way!) is in the second line: "now dead." I felt a sense of ambiguity about these words when reading them: Is the speaker dead? Is the city dead? Has some characteristic of the speaker died? I thought this very powerfully conveyed the feeling of loss built up upon in the poem. And, of course, the words take greater emphasis as they are offset by a comma and the line ends with a hard stop.
ReplyDeleteI cannot decide if "cinder city" sounds better to me than "city of cinder." I like the theme. Viewing the transition from childhood to adulthood as a kind of death has been on my mind since Okwiri Oduor mentioned it.
ReplyDeleteHi Lindsey! Great work! I really like the progression of the poem. There is a heavy sense of loss for the narrator. Going off of Dimitra and Cansona's comments--- the idea of death as this narrator enters adulthood works well with this setting that is rapidly crumbling. I like the ambiguity of how this death/decay is happening and the images associated with it. A suggestion for revision would be to think about the narrator's distance from girlhood and whether you want to convey more of a distance/separation from the death of that life, or if you want to convey more of a blur between the two worlds (of girlhood and adulthood) in which this speaker resides.
ReplyDeleteThis poem depicts the memory of the speaker’s as a decaying otherworld in which the speaker’s younger self exists as a separate entity. It contains many interesting and unexpected images (piano keys “prickled off,” the toy gun), and in that vein I would advise you to consider restructuring the piece to get more mileage out of the physical objects and tell the narrative through them. The first line of the poem seems a little too directly related to the title, self-referential, or talked-around (we know that “progression” refers to aging so why pick so ambiguous a word?) to really grab me, especially because a lot of the rest of what follows does.
ReplyDeleteYou tell a very clear story in lyrical verse. The story of the old piano (also the dead hopes and dreams) comes out very strongly. So, the balance between image/poetry and story is great.
ReplyDeleteI thought this was such an imaginative direction to take with the list of words we'd been given! And the entire poem - both this original and the revised version we read in class today - felt very cinematic. There's a wonderful austerity to the images and a nice momentum between them. The interplay of small, close objects, and large distant ones may also be what's giving me that sense.
ReplyDelete