Lannan Seminar

Lannan Seminar
notebooks

Tuesday, February 17, 2015

A Blank Canvas


The morning light is quite different to the afternoon’s, my body tells me as I make my way out of bed onto the piano stool in my room. The morning is quiet. Well, the birds don’t count; their chirping isn’t noise. The morning wind is also more pleasant; a breeze that touches my neighbor’s plants, plants dancing outside my window, under the scorching sun, breathing the city’s humidity and tropical air. I open my music book and practice “Frère Jacques” until I can’t hear it anymore, and then I allow myself to write some songs of my own. They are different to the ones in my music book. They aren’t necessarily intended for children like nursery rhymes, but they are still extremely cheesy. A fairy tale, a place to dream, let your imagination fly and reach the clouds, the lyrics went? I was probably an awful composer at age ten. Definitely an awful lyricist. But I always tried. I still look around me for inspiration and feel like an idiot for not being able to make the world justice. Did I think I would find talent with time? I still try. Whenever I hold a pen in my hand, my thoughts make their way to the paper—okay. But to what use, if it looks ugly? I do have gracious handwriting and intentions, but that’s too superficial. My words ruin the whiteness of the paper. In fact, it has more value without the words on it. I shouldn’t touch the paper. 

Maybe I’m just a blank canvas. Sometimes, it’s exciting being blank. I adventure in any direction I like. Other times, it bores me to death. Almost literally.

10 comments:

  1. The stream of consciousness is heightened with the short punchiness and honesty in the lines. A good sense of character is established.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This almost seems like a monologue, especially because it addresses the listener at points, which is engaging. I loved the line about the city's humidity and tropical air, since I don't usually associate tropicality with urban life, and I think drawing out that juxtaposition even farther could add a cool dimension to this piece.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The rhetorical questions included have the effect of engaging the reader in the story, and the lyrics of the song composed by the poet offer a unique vision into the personality and thought process of the speaker. The continual breakdown in the esteem of the speaker heightens the effect of the final paragraph, giving a piece that begins with a light-hearted tone a final note of morbidity.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is very strong, but I also thought that some editing (trimming, cutting) would make it even better. Here is another version, with suggested edits—
    The morning light is quite different to the afternoon’s. I make my way out of bed onto the piano stool in my room. The morning is quiet. The birds don’t count. The morning wind is also more pleasant; a breeze that touches my neighbor’s plants, plants dancing outside my window, under the scorching sun, breathing the city’s tropical air. I open my music book and practice “Frère Jacques” until I can’t hear it anymore, and then I write some songs of my own. They are different to the ones in my music book. They aren’t necessarily intended for children like nursery rhymes. A fairy tale, a place to dream, let your imagination fly and reach the clouds, the lyrics went? I was probably an awful composer. But I always tried. I still look around me for inspiration but am unable to do the world justice. Did I think I would find talent with time? I still try. Whenever I hold a pen in my hand, my thoughts make their way to the paper—okay. But to what use? I do have gracious handwriting and intentions but my words ruin the whiteness of the paper. In fact, it has more value without the words on it. I shouldn’t touch paper.

    What do you think? I was hoping for a bit more compression, and a slightly less conversational tone. I wanted the reader to intuit that the speaker is talking about herself as a child and also now. This is, however, a very fine first draft!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I generally really liked this. That said, and I can see others have already touched this, it could use a bit of a diet. There are some extraneous phrases and words that don't forward the narrative. It may be that you can make a strong argument for them or there is some meaning I am missing, but I would rip about 10-15% of the content out of this work and condense it.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I love the way you open this piece for a couple of reasons. One: you start at a place that is very different from where you end. Two: I don't know where precisely you're going to go, but the way you talk about light is somewhat defamiliarizing, and it draws me into this prose poem. I think if you tightened it up just a bit, your writing would be able to pack more of a punch.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I like the voice created here, you imbue the poem with a personality more akin to prose. I also like the contrasts you demonstrate - morning light vs. afternoon, chirping as music vs. noise, a traditional song vs. your own, written page vs. blank canvas

    ReplyDelete
  8. There are excellent suggestions for compressing this piece above. Still, I'm sad to see the use of "adventure" as a verb fall to the editor's knife; I like it so much that I hope you use it in another piece.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The speaker’s first-person internal stream-of-consciousness dialogue throughout this poem ends up seemingly like a kind of meditation, sometimes alive to wonder and sometimes pessimistic, about what it means to be an artist or a creator. The implication at the end is substantially darker than the rest of the piece would lead one to expect — I wonder if you think the more whimsical tone taken above rings discordant with what follows, or if it deliberately plays against it?

    ReplyDelete
  10. The stream-of-consciousness and rhetorical questions work nicely together. I really like the line "Sometimes, it’s exciting being blank" because the speaker is so clearly not blank. I agree with Ian, though, that the tone seems to shift jarringly. The last line also seems a bit forced--"almost literally."

    ReplyDelete