I have a memory. I may not have it later even though I know
it is there. It can be like losing a passage in a novel that way.
It snowed and we ran together across brightly lit fields. We
forgave whatever we could and ignored the rest. We went sledding and fell into
the creek at the bottom. Burning fingers clawed at the bank and we lifted
ourselves from the water to go again. When we were tired, we smoked stolen
cigarettes and insulted each other. But no one fought, or got killed, or went
to prison. The end.
This work is very effective at communicating a larger narrative in a short amount of space. The use of details is well done.
ReplyDeleteI liked the short sentence structure here. It feels clipped and staccato, which reverberates with the content of the piece. I'm curious about who the "we" in this poem is. It's interesting that one can have a memory that contains a central "we," and yet the other person (or persons) to whom the memory refers may have no knowledge of this bit.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Taylor regarding the manner in which this piece implies a much larger story than the one it is actually telling. I also agree with Kayla that the use of "we" here is very intriguing, and I think the sense of ambiguity it evokes works well with the style of the poem. I appreciated the separation of uses of "I" and "we" into separate stanza/paragraphs - this indicated the time difference of the two thoughts well. The ending (The end.) indicated a naive, almost child-like quality in the speaker, at least in the sense that they refuse to acknowledge the tragic events alluded to in the previous sentence.
ReplyDeleteI like this a lot. But I want to know whom the cigarettes are stolen from!
ReplyDeleteI like how you set up the brief story with a very apt simile. It accurately describes how memory functions and lends support to the powerful vignette that you compose. Well done!
ReplyDeleteThe first three sentences set up the reader with knowledge that not only will a specific memory be recounted here, but also give a fairly blunt assessment of the nature of memory. The memory itself is told in a very straightforward manner. I think what really engages me, though, is the sentence "We forgave whatever we could and ignored the rest." It seems to have slipped in there surreptitiously, and really deepens the memory being discussed here. There is a lot more emotional content to the memory beyond the concrete physical details recalled, and this sentence does a great job of succinctly evoking that.
ReplyDeleteThis is a very succinct story and I believe that it effectively conveyed the message that you were trying to create. I agree with Ben that we want to know more about some of the plot elements. I didn't feel that these omissions added anything.
ReplyDeleteThe strength of this piece lies in its ideas, its actions. Coolly irreverent. I see what you did there...although I want to SEE just a little more (in terms of imagery).
ReplyDeleteUnlike Eman, I feel the strength of the piece lies in its specific images ("Burning fingers clawed at the bank and we lifted ourselves from the water to go again. When we were tired, we smoked stolen cigarettes and insulted each other.") They really give the reader a sense of place and specificity--this isn't just a vague snow day story, it is a specific one ("burning fingers"--how wonderful!). The ending is also great in the way it so succinctly shows the reader that this is just a mundane, personal memory with no greater importance ("But no one fought, or got killed, or went to prison. The end."), but that is precisely WHY it is important to the speaker. You do a lot with very little.
ReplyDeleteI love how this piece tells a complete story in such a short time. The short sentences really do a good job of not bogging down the story. I really liked when you switched "memory" to "February" in the workshop. I would definitely recommend keeping that switch.
ReplyDelete